No matter how great the game looks or how jealous we are of the people who got lucky due to Toys R Us messing up and selling it before the 21st, the fact of the matter is Bioshock is NOT being released early.
I just got off the phone with one of the PR guys over at 2K. According to him, this whole situation was just a broken street date by some Toys R Us employees who didn't know Bioshock had a street date (or didn't care), and the resulting snowball effect that caused. At this point 2K isn't entirely sure why so many Toys R Us stores went and sold the game early ("It's not like street dates are a new concept"), but they are going to look into it once they put out this fire. (Check the update below for one reason why the street date may have been broken so widely.)
He also mentioned that they've been trying to control this whole thing all morning ("It is getting a little ridiculous"), and that they really didn't know why so many people were convinced the release date would be moved up a week when they haven't announced anything.
Look for an official press release from 2K fairly soon, as they were working on it when I finally got hold of them.
*UPDATE* I've been getting a lot of emails from people who work at TRU, or who have spoken to the managers. From what they're saying, there's no real clear indication on the packaging, boxes, or in their computer system that Bioshock has a street date of August 21. Which company is at fault for that? Right now, I don't know. I'll post more as I hear back from other sources.
The Q Big titles of Q4
Listen Up Video Games Live in Philly
Eddie Inzauto The games industry is doomed? Not really.
FilmPLOSION! Snow White and the Seven Dwarfs Blu-ray Review
Brendon Lindsey Lazy Game Journalism
Pro Tip Pro Tip: Demon's Souls
OneWordReview OWR: Kingdom Hearts
You Win! "That Makes Sense" Award
Head 2 Head Nathan Drake vs. Indiana Jones
Jason Fanelli Open Challenge to "Fair Journalism"
Tyler Cameron When Enough is Enough
OLD SKOOL 8-Bit RPG: Dragon Warrior
VS Node VS Node No Bounds
Revisited No More Heroes, Revisited
Phil Williams Games On Demand - The Future?
Mike Murphy Fox News Bias on Gaming an Insult to Journalism
Top 5 Takedown Top 5 Zombie Games
Sometimes the cynic says, "Well, that's all a setup. They're getting lots of free hype and publicity for their game." Considering that TRU has been in the business of releasing games on time for so many years, it is sort of hard to believe that they could have done such a boner like this. <shrugs shoulders>
Even with the biggest games, some distributors will put it in a box with a bunch of nickel and dime games w/o any indication that there is a street date. As long as TRU has been in this business, we don't know how long the teenies had been working there or if their managers (who could also have been teenies) had worked the same shift with them so that the message got across. Congrats to those who got theirs early ... I am still willing to wait for the 21st.